AUTHENTIC OLD FASHIONED ITALIAN CREAM CAKE RECIPE WITH CREAM CHEESE FROSTING

Petticoat JUNKtion

Tooltip

This authentic Italian Cream Cake recipe is made the old-fashioned way from scratch with yummy cream cheese frosting.

AUTHENTIC OLD FASHIONED ITALIAN CREAM CAKE RECIPE WITH CREAM CHEESE FROSTING

THE BEST ITALIAN CREAM CAKE

Italian-cream-cheese-cake.jpg

The cake is a pain in the rear to make but worth all the pain. I once tried a shortcut I found in Southern Living Magazine and it was a bust.

Beat until stiff 5 egg whites. Cream together: 2 cups sugar 1 stick butter softened ½ cup Crisco Shortening 5 egg yolks 1 cup buttermilk 1 teaspoon baking soda

ITALIAN CREAM CAKE RECIPE INGREDIENTS

BEAT THE EGG WHITES

I find it easiest to separate the eggs and beat the egg whites before starting to mix together the other cake ingredients. Beat the egg whites until they are stiff. I use a glass bowl for the egg whites.

How-to-make-an-Italian-Cream-Cake.jpg

Cream the sugar, butter, and shortening together. Soften the butter before mixing. I use those handy dandy shortening sticks.

MIX THE INGREDIENTS

how-to-make-a-cake.jpg

Add the next four ingredients and mix well. The next step says to add the vanilla, nuts, and coconut and mix by hand but I use the mixer for this step too. Fold in the beaten egg whites by hand.

Swipe Up for all the Details